Pages

Thursday, August 17, 2017

PEOPLE OR POLITICS? ASEAN AT 50


By George I. H Cooke 

‘A people-oriented and people-centered ASEAN’ are among the core principles of the Philippines’ chairmanship of the South East Asian grouping which marked its 50th anniversary in early August 2017. President Rodrigo Roa Duterte identified the people of the sub-region to be at the heart of community-development and stressed that people want ‘a stable source of livelihood, a roof over one’s head, quality education for their children, affordable healthcare, a peaceful and stable government and a dynamic economy.’ Hailing from a democracy in Asia, Duterte’s attention is justified, yet questions arise over the progress made in five decades, the prosperity wave in most of South East Asia and most importantly the impact of ASEAN on the people.

Half a century constitutes a significant milestone for reflection and review. Yet it also presents an opportunity to address challenges which could in time, overwhelm the grouping and even subsume in the long term. Regional groupings which made integration ‘fashionable’ over the last century have seen a diverse array of associations sprouting across the world. While the European Union (EU) and its initial Coal and Steel Pact paved the way for the countries of West Europe to converge, membership grew with the fall of the Berlin Wall and the wave of independence in most of East Europe after the Cold War. More than seven decades after the Coal and Steel Pact, it remains uncertain whether the current level of integration was first envisaged. Whilst Britain cast a shadow over the Union with Brexit, the concept of integration is the most challenged.

Other regional bodies, though not comparable, have attempted to follow a similar course. In 1967, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore and Thailand sought to create a model based on unity, solidarity and cooperation. The Founding Fathers of ASEAN, the Foreign Ministers of these five countries signed the five-articled ASEAN Charter in Bangkok commencing a journey that would see Brunei Darussalam join nearly two decades later in 1984, Vietnam in 1995, Laos and Myanmar in 1997 and Cambodia two years later. They all called for strengthened solidarity, adaptation to times, development of a framework, and the upliftment of a region. The then Philippine Foreign Secretary, Narciso Ramos explained that the negotiation process ‘truly taxed the goodwill, the imagination, the patience and understanding of the five participating Ministers.’ Resolute on the need for cooperation, he identified that their ‘fragmented economies…carry the seeds of weakness in their incapacity for growth, and their self-perpetuating dependence on the advanced, industrial nations.’

Ramos and Duterte sing off the same sheet. They both envision the grouping making substantial progress. The difference is that they spoke fifty years apart. In 1967, Ramos wanted ASEAN to ‘marshal the still untapped potentials of this rich region through more substantial united action.’ The noble aspirations were expressed at a time when Vietnam was in conflict and American forces were present. Fifty years later though not Vietnam at war, and despite American forces still being present, though in limited numbers and for varying reasons, the countries have prospered.

Statistics from member states in ASEAN indicate progress. While the total population grew from 317 million in 1990 to 617 million in 2012, total GDP expanded from US$334 billion to US$ 2, 311 billion during that same period, and bound to US$2.6 trillion last year. Total trade of these ten countries rose from US$ 306 billion in 1990 to US$ 2, 436 billion, while intra-regional trade increased from US$144 billion to US$602 billion. This indicates that in 1990 intra-regional trade amounted to nearly 50% of total trade of the ASEAN region while in 2012 it had dipped to 24%.

This halving of intra-regional trade comes despite the Association planning for a common economic programme since 2007, the ASEAN Economic Community. Based on four pillars of a single market and production base, competitive economic region, equitable economic development and integration in the globalized economy, the Community is geared towards harnessing the capacity of a regional economy which is the seventh-largest in the world, and a population estimated to amount to 620 million at present, making it the third largest third in Asia after China and India. This reduction in intra-regional trade could be attributed to new ventures and trading opportunities outside the region which attracted the attention of ASEAN member states.

Despite the opportunities that exist for the region, it is clear that challenges abound. From an absence on interest in forging a political or monetary union, to the divide in development between founding and new member states, the difficulty of forging an ASEAN identity and the concern over language, all contribute towards withholding progress. The lack of a strong secretariat, as is the experience with the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), also lends to a lack of promotion of the regional identity. The European Commission was established (EC) to look after all matters regional. Tasked with promoting the interests of the Union, the EC is unlike any body within other regional groupings. The centre is strong, hence the attribution of the degree of progress experienced in the EU model. ASEAN is not alone in this regard, but neither are those other bodies as old as ASEAN.

Will ASEAN look at creating a single political entity or prefer to merely profess political cooperation and have leaders meet frequently? Is the region keen on merging national economies in producing a common market? Are member states focused on building their own national economies or truly strengthening regional capacity? Have the people of the member states, from all walks of life been able to grasp the operation of ASEAN? Has ASEAN reached beyond the leaders and the private sectors of the member states?

Until and unless the challenges ahead are addressed in the spirit of forging a common identity, the success attributed to the ASEAN region could well be attached to individual countries, their own economic planning and development programmes, rather than have it ascribed to regionalism. It is remarkable that success has been made, but the question pivots on the realization that it is the political arena that brags about it. People need to experience the fruits of integration, and people will forge much more than just the identity of ASEAN, that was first envisaged. Only then will ‘a people-oriented and people-centered ASEAN’ be created.  


Saturday, July 29, 2017

Agreements and Anniversaries: China, India and Sri Lanka’s Foreign Policy - 1987 and 2017



The foreign policy of a country, whilst being an extension of its domestic policy, is chiefly the manner in which it deals, responds and cooperates with the international community. Hardly set it stone, the policy and policy making process evolve according to circumstance and situation. Thus it is of added significance when the country formulating that policy is a relatively small state, attempting to balance its policy towards two of the largest states in the world. Adapting to developments at the national, regional and global level, while strategizing for the future, remains at the core of decision making.   

Sri Lanka’s relations with the global community date back centuries, with the importance of the country’s location being paramount. Apparent through the manner in which other countries have sought to maintain ties, Ceylon has from the times of the ancient kings, and the special envoys they dispatched to foreign courts, to the heightened commercial connectivity along the trading routes and through to the colonial period, when three of the most powerful empire builders of their time, sought to ‘engage’ with the country, in more ways than one, experienced a foreign policy that has been complex, competitive, and colourful to say the least.

From independence onwards, the country has striven to be ‘a friend to all and enemy to none’ in the international community, yet faced trying and decisive moments when decisions were taken, or forced to be taken, owing to a plethora of factors. A noteworthy degree of this engagement and these decisive moments have pivoted on relations with China and India.

With China, from the recognition accorded by D. S. Senanayake in 1950, to the Rubber-Rice Pact during the premiership of Dudley Senanayake in 1952, S. W. R. D. Bandaranaike’s decision to establish diplomatic relations in 1957, Sirimavo Bandaranaike’s engagement in shuttle diplomacy at the time of border tensions between China and India in 1962, and her close ties with Mao Tse Tung and Chou en Lai, as well as the diplomatic engagement of all Presidents from J. R. Jayewardene to Maithripala Sirisena, have seen a steady, sometimes meteoric rise in connectivity, as during the period from 2005 to 2015, with even Xi Jinping visiting Sri Lanka in 2014. The Chinese stake in the development drive is high in Sri Lanka. These are not funds that China chose to freely pour into the Sri Lankan economy, but instead loans that Sri Lanka sought. Hence while China looks to expand its sphere of influence globally and finds a ready partner in Sri Lanka, it is of paramount importance to note that Sri Lanka reached out to China and that country reciprocated. Terms and conditions that accompany such finances, and through them prosperity, obviously come at a cost, as would be the case with all loans.

India, given its geographic proximity has remained a critical factor in policy formulation. Whilst independence itself in 1948 is attributed to the freedom struggle on the island, the departure of the British from India remains a pivotal factor that is often overlooked. The signing of vital agreements with the British to safeguard defence and external relations by D. S. Senanayake owing to his anxiety of having to ward off any untoward action, to the strong bond of friendship between Nehru and the Bandaranaikes, which continued through Indira Gandhi and Sirimavo Bandaranaike, the Sirima-Shastri Pact of 1964, claiming the island of Kachchativu in 1974, the training of rebels by Mrs Gandhi and her deep dislike of J. R. Jayewardene as well as the infamous humanitarian air intervention by India in the north of Sri Lanka and the signing of the Indo-Lanka Accord in 1987 between Rajiv Gandhi and J. R. Jayewardene, the saga that was the Indian Peace Keeping Force and the action of Ranasinghe Premadasa, the closeness of relations during the presidency of Chandrika Bandaranaike Kumaratunga, the straining of them in the second term of Mahinda Rajapaksa, and the intimacy of ties post 2015 with Narendi Modi having visited Sri Lanka twice in two years, have all seen the formulation of policy with India remaining a cornerstone in the foreign policy framework.

29th July 2017 marks three decades since the signing of the Indo-Lanka Accord, the assault on Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi and the first steps towards the establishment of the Provincial Council system. Politics remained at the core as India, her coterie of diplomats and abundance of politicians from Tamil Nadu to New Delhi took umbrage at developments in the island.

Reflecting on the period, the Oxford educated, political heavyweight Lalith Athulathmudali once observed that ‘the Indians came in only because we were winning. …Their purpose was to use our acute problem, which they helped to intensify, in order to get us to change our policy on several points.’ A domestic issue had spiraled into an international one as global attention turned to the island with the riots of July 1983. As refugees sought asylum overseas the issue ceased to be domestic. Whilst Jayewardene sought the support of the United States of America and the Western world, especially through his open market policies, his tackling of relations with his immediate neighbour, remained critical.

Yet his attempting to cooperate with Rajiv Gandhi, especially in light of the already deep-rooted involvement of India, even won them both a nomination for the Nobel Peace Prize in 1988 but which was eventually secured by the UN Peace Keeping Forces. From 1987 to date relations with India have soured and improved at varied times, signaling change yet the abiding factor has been the need for positive relations owing to geography. Elections and their results do not move the island nation from its geographic positioning, and hence, neighbours do not change. Jayewardene and almost all his successors have understood the need to work with a country they wouldn’t be able to survive without.

In the last three decades China has experienced a steady rise as a global power, marking her presence on the world stage and surging ahead of countries like India, in a gamut of areas. Interestingly the thirtieth anniversary of the Indo-Lanka Accord coincides, with the signing of a landmark agreement with China over the Hambantota port, which lies in close proximity to international sea lanes and is one of the many assets Sri Lanka possesses.

Once again we are reminded that foreign policy remains an extension of domestic policy. Domestic compulsions continue to drive foreign policy and its formulation as Sri Lanka, having undergone a virtual stagnation of economy growth and development, sacrificing prosperity and losing out on the opportunities due to the conflict, is attempting today to regain her position in the region and the world at large. Countries like Singapore which took a cue from then Ceylon have raced ahead and are in the vanguard of global affairs. South East Asia, since adopting a collaborative mechanism in 1967 is reaping immense benefits fifty years later, while others in South Asia are trying to ride the wave of the One Belt One Road initiative of China.      

Sri Lanka’s choice to proceed with the signing of the Agreement with China, to service the debt and ensure usage of facilities the country possesses, is judicious, to say the least. The agreement is a lease and needs to be understood as such. At the same time the efforts to lease the Trincomalee oil tanks in the East to India indicate the ability of a small island nation to balance her foreign policy. Satisfying two global giants at the same time, involves massive effort, dedication and strategy. Evidenced through the action of the Sirisena - Wickremesinghe government is that bipartisan cooperation can bring about change, which would transcend into prosperity of the island and her people.  
 
Foreign policy is therefore not set in stone, yet strategy remains a crucial element if a state is to benefit from location, resources and infrastructure. The maturity of the process of policy making makes it clear that irrespective of developments in China or India, and despite the international machinations enveloping these two countries, Sri Lanka, her leaders and people, need to focus on a strategic, Sri Lanka-first policy through which the state’s interests are safeguarded, sustained and promoted. That policy needs to be set in stone. 

- AWARELOGUE EDITORIAL



Sunday, July 9, 2017

GUEST COMMENTARY - MERCANTILISM: HAS IT LOST ITS RELEVANCE?

Mercantilism, which is the earliest theory pertaining to International Trade, was the dominant economic doctrine in the 16th, 17th and 18th centuries, and is often discussed with reference to colonialism as Mercantilism is considered to be a result of Colonialization. In the past, this was based on the premise that national wealth and power were best served by increasing exports and collecting precious metals in return. Therefore, a country’s economy was mainly controlled by the state, chiefly through corporations and trading companies. Through this approach the main intention of nation states was to increase their power by sustaining a positive balance of trade. 

With the passage of time, Mercantilism was rejected by scholars such as Adam Smith and David Ricardo who promoted free trade among nations.  However, today once again states are already beginning and/or are considering the use of inward looking protectionist trade policies as they begin to discover certain flaws in following an extremely liberal trade policy. Hence we see several leading economies in the world moving towards more neo-mercantilist trade policies in order to maintain their power in the international system.

When examining the relevance of Mercantilism to contemporary global trade, it is important to pay attention to the following characteristics of Mercantilism:
·            State-led economy
·            Export based economy with minimum imports (balance of trade theory) and implementing high tax and tariff policies when importing goods to countries (a nationalist approach)
·            The concept of bullionism
·            Maximising the use of domestic resources
·            Provision of subsidies for profitable industries.
In this Mercantilist approach to trade, states possessed the supreme power over trade and the state formulated economic policies in such a way that they can reap the maximum advantage by accumulating more wealth and thereby becoming more powerful as a nation. Hence it is a zero-sum game which is more advantageous to developed economies. The primary method of calculation of wealth of a country was by looking at its gold and silver reserves which was known as bullionism and this was one manner utilised by Western imperialists to accumulate wealth. Mercantilists firmly believed that the more gold a country possessed, the more powerful and wealthier it was.  Certain imperial powers also had navigation acts which restricted the ability of other nation to trade with the colonies that were under the rule of these imperial powers.

Along with this, they also followed a favourable balance of trade in which the economy was mainly export oriented with a minimum number of imports. To support this policy, they implemented high rates of taxes and tariffs for imports and at the same time the government provided with subsidies for local manufacturers. This led to the strengthening of local producers and discouraged imports from other countries. Hence the Mercantilist approach was a nationalist economic policy.

While from an initial overview it seems as if this theory is quite obsolete, when we carefully examine the current economic situation of the world we can see that several countries, specifically developed economies, still prefer and try to utilise Mercantilist approaches to trade under the guise of capitalism and free trade. However, unlike in the past, the concept of bullionism is not so prominent in modern mercantilism because today there are more sophisticated ways of calculating a country’s wealth like the Gross Domestic Production (GDP), Gross National Production (GNP), etc.

However, even after centuries, although it is not as popular as it used to be during the colonial period, the essence of Mercantilism, i.e. maximising net exports in order to prosper the national economy, remains the same. Just like companies such as the British East India Company enjoyed the trade monopoly, in the modern era also it is observed that several global powers have held monopoly for certain goods. For example, the Organization for Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), has maintained the monopoly for crude oil up until recent past. Although this is a regional organization which goes beyond the national boundaries of one particular country, they have made sure that no other country or trade union outside their region can compete with them when controlling the global price for crude oil. Through this these countries make sure that the middle eastern oil rich countries remain powerful actors in the arena of global trade, particularly in oil exports. Hence, going along the lines of the realist school of thought, all these attempts of states are to maximise their power by becoming economically and politically strong.

Apart from regional cartels like OPEC, most of the world’s richest countries who claim to be fully committed to free trade and trade unions, are very much Mercantilist in some of their economic policies. One such example is China, who claims to have a state driven capitalist economy. Although at a superficial level this is what can be observed, China, in fact has underlying protectionist resolutions in each economic and trade related decision they venture into. They have purposely undervalued their currency and they deliberately subsidise the goods they export to other countries so that they will have a trade surplus. Anti-dumping, one of the most detrimental instruments of protection, is another famous technique used by countries like China in order to drive other firms out of the market and create a kind of monopoly in the global market regarding several trade items.

When we look into the Latin American region, we find Mexico as a perfect example of modern day Mercantilist economy. An ideal example from Mexico is Telmex, a Mexican telephone company which was initially owned by the government and later in the 1990s it was privatised and this was essentially a state grant of the telephone monopoly to a private business. Even today, Telmex enjoys telephone monopoly and the adverse result of this is that the company does not take sufficient endeavours to improve the quality of their service and satisfy the consumers. In order to avoid budding companies entering into the market, Telmax engages in lobbying politicians, controlling regulatory bodies, proposing favourable laws, etc. (Conroy, 2005). Situations such as this limit the options for consumers. It is true that the local companies prosper through these measures, but the consumers who are on the receiving end are at disadvantage because they are deprived of being exposed to other options available and choosing what perfectly suits their taste.

Even though Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) have actually made trade with developed countries more accessible for the developed world, mercantilism approaches within these trade agreements are still visible. The best example for this is the South Asian Free Trade Agreement (SAFTA). Even though the FTA made trade between India and Sri Lanka is much compatible, non-tariff barriers have made the trade agreement ineffective and inefficient. On the other hand, the trade agreement has made India reap more benefits with the strategy of white list and this is quite similar to what could be seen during the Mercantilist era. Such examples depict the fact that even though free trade exists between countries, it has failed and still fails to lift off the trade gaps and close the technological and development barriers which could be seen within developed and developing nations. The Doha Round and the Bali package are other examples where the developing countries’ needs have not been addressed by the developed countries. This also proves that countries especially developed nations prefer mercantilism approach compared to developing nations who prefer free trade agreements. 

Furthermore, Chinese One Belt One Road (OBOR) and the United States President withdrawing from regional trade agreements such as the Transatlantic Trade Investment Partnership (TTIP) and Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) clearly define the diversified strategies countries tend to follow. Developed nations such as United States prefer a protectionist, more conservative and demand driven trade policies. The idea behind this is Mercantilism where the president tries to strengthen the local entrepreneurs in the means of smart trade. On the other hand, China develops a theory of an open market system which underlies political dominance over the region. The strengths in the two economies has actually led to such policies. For example, the Chinese open their markets because of the fact that they have surplus of cheap labour and US because of their high unemployment rate.

Therefore, one cannot simply say that Mercantilism is an obsolete economic concept because the essence of mercantilism is seen in global trade even in this globalized, technologically advanced 21st world market. In fact, the tendency of going back to Mercantilism by developed economies is on the rise. Therefore, Mercantilism is still a prominent approach in contemporary global trade and will continue to remain relevant as long as nation states exist.
-
          - Guest Commentary : Harini Fernando



Saturday, July 8, 2017

JAPAN, EU AND ASIA: SYNERGIZING INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION


A century and a half ago, with the Meiji Restoration in 1868, Japan commenced its ascent as a global power. The race towards industrialization was gripping the West, and not wanting to be left out Japan adopted the slogan ‘Fukoku Kyohei’ meaning ‘Enrich the Country, Strengthen the Armed Forces,’ and  joined the rapacious pursuit of grabbing power through the establishment of a colonial empire. The empire grew rapidly, military success followed, and so did defeat, resulting in occupation, dissolution of the empire and the promulgation of a new constitution in 1947.
 
Seven decades later Japan is not merely a rising star of the East, but has achieved that which was envisioned in 1868 - a state which is industrially advanced, economically sound and politically crucial. Whilst the nuclear attacks caused untold devastation, what was more destructive was the loss of prestige and position the country had hitherto enjoyed. Yet those who attacked, also sought to re-build, and ensured the newly emerging state would be able to regain that which it lost and more importantly, a former enemy became a close ally. The formula that worked in Japan is one that America has attempted to replicate elsewhere. From intervention in numerous states in Asia and the Arab world, the United States has sought to attack and rebuild, change regimes and introduce new players, critically crush and then financially support, but that which worked in Japan, does not appear keen on reaching fruition in other conflicts.

Through its control of the Asian Development Bank, Japan has been able to win over former enemies through financial assistance. A country once detested in most of Asia for its colonial past, is today admired, respected and relied upon across the world. Thus the trade deal with the European Union is being touted as a ‘slap in the face’ of Donald Trump whose preferences for protectionism over free trade has seen America turning its back on the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) and opting instead to protect all things American.

Yet the deal, hailed as a landmark, could be viewed from three angles for its advantageous nature and opportunity - for the Japanese, the Europeans and Asians.   

Facing stiff competition in the region and globally, Japan and China have found it difficult to put the past behind them. While the Mukden Incident in 1931 led to the Japanese invasion of Manchuria, the defeat of the Chinese and the creation of the puppet state of Manchukuo eroded normalcy and led to continued strife. The animosity continues to date. With China going global with its One Belt One Road initiative as it uses its historic trading paths and partners, Japan doesn’t want to be left out.  

Visiting Washington in February 2017, Shinzo Abe explored the possibility of a trade deal with Trump. As the new American President had opted to turn his back on the TPP, Japan was hopeful of using the hard bargaining that had been done in the past over the TPP but Trump wasn’t interested in what had been done and instead chose to nitpick over trade barriers that existed. A deal with America is still far off.

While the Americans dragged their feet with the Japanese, the Europeans didn’t. Embittered by the Brexit issue, the EU now in its sixtieth year, is looking for success stories and where better to find one that with a star of the East. Whilst the last year has been disastrous for moving integration further down the road, as the EU reeled from the British vote, the Europeans waited for the invocation of Article 50. In true British fashion, Theresa May delayed invoking it, and soon thereafter called for a snap general election in one of her worst gambles, which she must certainly regret today.

The European model has evolved over time. From the Coal and Steel Pact to what it is today, the EU is unsurpassed in regional integration. The opportunity of collaborating with countries like China and Japan enhance the potential of the grouping and the countries within it. The OBOR and China have already been embraced in much of the EU. Xi Jinping is welcome across the region and countries have been at pains to improve cooperation mechanisms with China, having realized the scope such relationships portend for their own future.

With the breakdown of the TPP, the EU saw opportunity in speeding up trade talks with Japan, which had commenced in 2013. EU exports to Japan are expected to increase by 34%, while Japan’s exports are forecast to rise 29%. Coming soon after the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement with Canada in May, the EU has added another feather to its cap, in expanding free trade. Aspiring towards a similar arrangement with the world’s fastest growing economy, the Europeans are focused on India, where a market of 1.2 billion is as lucrative as they could ever hope for.     

Irrespective of whether the trading arrangement is with China, Japan or India, the region that would benefit is Asia. In the spirit of realizing the Asian Century the contributions being made by China, Japan and India are massive. The numerous countries of Asia, irrespective of inherent differences, bear an ‘Asian’ identity, are geographically joined and politically maintain strong linkages with some or all of these three. The spillover effects of such trading arrangements such as the Japan - EU Economic Partnership Agreement provide hitherto untapped prospects, especially for smaller states in Asia, and those which are closest to the big three.  

Apparent as it is, that each of these states possess immense potential through their cooperation with the world, potential and possibility would be insurmountable if they choose to work together, and use that synergy in their global interactions. History remains relevant, yet past misgivings only cloud a bright future.
-         
 -          -    Awarelogue Editorial